Securities Litigation Reform

Private securities class actions are lawsuits filed on behalf of shareholders against publicly—traded companies that allegedly defrauded their investors. Supporters of these cases claim they are necessary to compensate shareholders and deter wrongdoing by corporations. However, the primary beneficiaries of securities class actions are plaintiffs’ lawyers, not investors. At the same time, these cases threaten the health of the U.S. economy by imposing huge costs on American businesses, investors, and employees, while hurting the global competiveness of U.S. securities markets and serve as a barrier to private companies considering whether to become public. Read More...

There is enormous pressure on companies to settle securities class actions because of the burden they impose on management, the cost of going to trial, and the risk of a runaway verdict. This dynamic typically results in major settlements even when the underlying claims are of questionable merit. Even if a claim is legitimate, a settlement effectively results in one group of innocent shareholders (those who own shares at the time of the settlement) paying another group of innocent shareholders. The individuals responsible for wrongdoing rarely make a significant contribution. In addition, recoveries usually amount to just pennies on the dollar of alleged losses, while plaintiffs’ lawyers walk away with marge contingency fees. Those whom the securities class action system is supposed to protect—small, individual retail investors—are the ones who, in fact, benefit the least.

The current system is also plagued by abuse. In fact, several leading securities plaintiffs’ lawyers were sent to prison for offering bribes and kickbacks to potential plaintiffs. The integrity of the securities class action system is further undermined by a legal “pay–to–play” culture of corruption in which lawyers make political contributions to the politicians charged with deciding who will represent large public pension funds as lead plaintiffs in these suits–and thus who will collect the largest share of attorneys’ fees from future settlements.

The securities litigation system also hurts the global competitiveness of U.S. securities markets. Companies actively question whether they want to access the U.S. securities markets and expose themselves to the exceptional liability our system imposes. Furthermore, the risk of liability is something too great for companies to move from being privately held to public.  

Plaintiffs' lawyers also sue companies involved in a merger or acquisition in state courts. This lucrative form of litigation occurs because the parties to the merger want to close their deal quickly, thus allowing plaintiffs’ lawyers to hold the merger hostage through the use of multiple lawsuits. The clear majority of these suits settle quickly and, like other types of securities litigation, typically provide little or no benefit to shareholders. But the settlements do result in large fees to the plaintiffs' lawyers who filed the lawsuits. While the courts, including those in Delaware (where many publicaly traded companies are incorporated), are beginning to look unfavorably on this type of litigation, it is still an open question whether this type of spurious litigation is going to be put to a stop. 

To curb securities litigation abuses, Congress should consider commonsense reforms that would expose relationships between securities class action attorneys and plaintiffs, target “pay–to–play” conflicts between plaintiffs’ attorneys and state pension fund officials, and introduce a competitive bidding process for selecting lead plaintiffs’ attorneys in securities class actions. In addition, Congress and state legislatures should consider measures to limit forum shopping and other abuses related to mergers and acquisitions litigation.

Suggested Resources

Research

All Results for Securities Litigation Reform

  1. Supreme Court Rules on International Claims & Class Actions

    January 15, 2014 | News and Blog

    On Tuesday, the Supreme Court dismissed a lawsuit filed in California court against German automaker Daimler AG for alleged human rights violations in Argentina in the 1970s, unanimously ruling that American courts lack jurisdiction over the case.... Read More

  2. In the News Today - January 13, 2014

    January 13, 2014 | News and Blog

    A federal appeals court has decided that payments from the gulf oil spill settlement fund may continue, despite objections from BP that the fund is paying for inflated and fraudulent claims.... Read More

  3. In the News Today - January 8, 2014

    January 08, 2014 | News and Blog

    Drafters of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act filed an amicus brief in the Halliburton fraud-on-the-market case, writing that the 1995 law did not address the theory.... Read More

  4. In the News Today - January 6, 2014

    January 06, 2014 | News and Blog

    The American Lawyer looks forward to securities litigation in the new year, saying that there will likely be fewer settlements related to the financial crisis since many of these cases have moved beyond the motion to dismiss stage.... Read More

  5. In the News Today - December 31, 2013

    December 31, 2013 | News and Blog

    The National Law Journal looks back at the major bellwether cases from 2013 and where they are heading in 2014.... Read More

  6. In the News Today - December 16, 2013

    December 16, 2013 | News and Blog

    Lawyers for plaintiffs and Toyota have asked a judge to establish an "intensive settlement process" for resolving hundreds of lawsuits over alleged instances of unintended acceleration. ... Read More

  7. In the News Today - December 16, 2013

    December 16, 2013 | News and Blog

    Lawyers for plaintiffs and Toyota have asked a judge to establish an "intensive settlement process" for resolving hundreds of lawsuits over alleged instances of unintended acceleration. ... Read More

  8. In the News Today - November 19, 2013

    November 19, 2013 | News and Blog

    A new report looks at plaintiffs who opt-out of securities class action settlements in order to pursue their own cases, which could take on added significance with the Supreme Court's decision to review the fraud on the market theory.... Read More

  9. In the News Today - November 15, 2013

    November 15, 2013 | News and Blog

    The Supreme Court is scheduled to weigh whether to grant certiorari in a suit challenging the "fraud on the market" theory, one of the bedrocks of securities class action litigation. ... Read More

  10. In the News Today - October 31, 2013

    October 31, 2013 | News and Blog

    The National Geographic Society is reportedly under investigation for possible FCPA violations in Egypt surrounding its dealings with an Egyptian archaeologist who served as a gatekeeper to the country's antiquities... Read More